In September 1971, regulation enforcement stormed New York’s Attica Correctional Facility and opened hearth on prisoners who had taken 38 guards hostage to demand primary human rights, together with entry to healthcare. State authorities killed 29 incarcerated folks and 10 correctional officers within the course of. Six weeks later, the governor of New York called for a Special Grand Jury investigation into the rebellion.
Inside a month of the takeover and subsequent bloodbath (because it was known as within the Pa’aho Press), the jail press started circulating commentaries on what occurred at Attica. The usually-controversial topic remained a frequent subject within the penal press. Folks opined on many sides of the disaster, the McKay Fee’s official investigation, and at last their report, which spawned much more commentary from incarcerated voices. Through Reveal Digital’s American Prison Newspapers assortment, contemporaneous accounts from incarcerated writers are actually obtainable on-line open entry.
To analyze the mass casualty occasion, the state appointed a Particular Deputy Lawyer Normal who shaped the Attica Job Drive. By November the governor had appointed a particular fee on Attica, chaired by NYU Regulation College Dean Robert B. McKay. The McKay Fee investigated the occasions that lead as much as and transpired throughout and after the rebellion, producing a 514-page report about it the subsequent 12 months.
References to Attica within the Penal Press, September 1971 – September 1972
Prisoners wrote about each main media and penal press protection of the rebellion on the New York jail. What’s Up, an Avon Park Correctional Establishment publication out of Florida, featured an article of their October 1, 1971, issue about previously incarcerated activist Joe Grant beginning the Worldwide Penal Digest for prisoners and former prisoners. The unnamed creator contrasted Grant’s perspective with the eye Attica acquired from “largely uninformed writers” sharing views within the media that had been “slanted by their shallow understanding and prejudices.”
Within the October 1971 issue of the Oklahoma State Penitentiary’s The Eye Opener, contributor Joe Carnes made a press release “TO THE PENAL PRESS,” acknowledging “an absence of any dialogue in regards to the Attica factor,” as a result of the editors and writers “really feel that it’s too sizzling an merchandise to the touch at the moment,” and since “the information media has stated it a lot stronger than we might ever dare.”
Members of the penal press reprinted a few of these indicting articles about Attica from legacy newspapers as effectively. In a chunk known as, “COMMENTARY ON PRISONS,” featured within the July 1972 issue of What’s Up and initially revealed by ABC Information in September 1971. Howard Ok. Smith, the author of the ABC piece, explicitly suggests there’s “one thing unsuitable with our prisons,” and that “it takes far gone despair for prisoners to strive what they tried in Attica, or in San Quentin” [—where guards assassinated the activist and writer George Jackson in August of 1971, broadly understood to be a precipitating event to Attica—] “or within the Tombs in New York, or in jail after jail earlier than that.” The period was fraught with jail uprisings and, for the primary time, the US skilled a rising nationwide consciousness that the uprisings belied issues not with the prisoners themselves however with the prisons to which they had been confined.
“Our underfunded prisons,” Howard Smith wrote for ABC, “commit 95 % of their assets to stopping prisoners from having [community ties] —to custody, to incarceration, to guarding him. Solely 5 % of funds go to schooling, to coaching, to experimentation with restricted freedom—the sorts of issues that create ties and roots.” Baked into the ABC Information correspondent’s evaluation is that if prisons had more cash, they’d fund extra rehabilitation-focused initiatives—lowering the necessity for prisons altogether—a notion that will prove false in coming decades as jail budgets soared however rehabilitative efforts dwindled.
As occasions at Attica targeted public consideration on the shortage of healthcare inside prisons within the US within the early Nineteen Seventies, Fortress, a Kentucky State Penitentiary publication, devoted two full pages within the June/July 1972 issue of the paper to reprinting a chunk, “MEDICAL UN-CARE FOR PRISONERS.” Within the piece, Dr. Frank Rundle, who beforehand labored because the chief psychiatrist at Soledad Jail, claims to have been fired as a result of he put the medical wants of prisoners above the wants of the establishment.
Ominously, Rundle translated the nervousness after the Attica rebellion right into a forecast for the long run:
[S]o lengthy as prisons as presently constituted exist, wherein a person’s life is sort of completely managed by the state, his whole helplessness in looking for medical care have to be thought of and affordable efforts made to supply first rate ranges of medical care. … If this isn’t achieved, an issue space which has contributed to violence and demise at Soledad, San Quentin and Attica will proceed to smoulder [sic]- – – – and convey additional destruction of life inside prisons.
Jail administrations shared his fears, and contributors to prisoner newspapers, understanding what was at stake, paid consideration. The January 22, 1972, issue of The Weekly Scene consists of an article reprinted from Columbia journal with feedback from a chaplain on the correctional facility in Elmira, New York, and the president of the American Correctional Affiliation. Each known as for separation of cooperative and recalcitrant prisoners “after the Attica riots,” and the chaplain championed the institution of “a most safety establishment for about 150 hardcore, militant, Marxist revolutionaries.” Although wildly divergent, it was a time of robust opinions round the way to modify the nation’s method to incarceration.
Curiosity in Unconventional Paradigms of Justice
Curiosity in numerous approaches to justice and incarceration surged across the time Attica exploded. With the implementation of a distinct system on the Washington State Penitentiary in Walla Walla, the place prisoners had been granted authority to control themselves, juxtaposition with Attica grew to become frequent within the pages of prisoner papers .
Though a visitor editorial that appeared in Best Scene a few months later tempered enthusiasm for this system—errors throughout the justice system, “whether or not too dangerous as in Attica, or ‘too good’ as in Walla Walla,” can elicit the ire of a complete nation—the penal press however observed Walla Walla’s promise, framing it as an alternative choice to the struggling Attica wrought.
A contribution to the April 1972 issue of Cummins Journal, disseminated by prisoners of the Arkansas Division of Corrections, reprinted from a prisoner paper in Rhode Island, quoted the incarcerated council president at Walla Walla, Johnnie Harris, who instructed, “If self-government hadn’t come when it did, we might have had one other Attica, or San Quentin, or Soledad.”
A reporter wrote within the November 1971 issue of the Grapevine newspaper, printed out of the Sumter Correctional Establishment in Bushnell, Florida, that the brand new system empowers a council of incarcerated individuals elected by different prisoners to make institutional selections and “appears headed towards the removing of the guards from contained in the partitions and, ultimately, to the removing of the partitions,” alluding to goals of jail abolition, a motion that gained steam during that decade.
After the McKay Fee Report
By September 1972, the McKay Fee had launched its report on Attica. In an issue of the Cummins Journal, launched the identical month, an editor’s be aware defined prisoners there had revealed a abstract of the 514-page report produced by the New York State Particular Fee on Attica. The abstract included direct quotes from the Fee concerning prisoner rights, a lot of which weren’t acknowledged earlier than or after Attica. “Prisoners ought to retain all rights besides that of liberty of individual,” reads the abstract, “together with the best to be adequately paid for work, to get and ship letters, to precise political opinions, follow or ignore faith, and to be protected towards abstract punishment.”
Come December 1972, the Pa’ahao Press, a Hawaiian jail newspaper that predates statehood there, featured a chunk titled, “MASSACRE REPORT”:
On September 13, 1972, a 12 months to the day of the Bloodbath at Attica, the 514-page official report from the Fee To Examine the Attica Jail Riot was launched—one 12 months since ‘Bloody Monday’ when state troopers had been ordered to ‘retake’ Attica State Jail and finish the 5-day seizure of the jail by over 2,000 prisoners. One 12 months for the reason that State of New York slaughtered 43 human beings, prisoners and guards alike.
The penal press evaluation of the McKay Fee’s findings identified the Fee’s harsh criticism of circumstances at Attica main as much as the rebellion, and even to the report’s repudiation of gratuitous state violence. The Pa’ahao Press contributor additionally took the Fee to activity for the “poor whitewash” of state terror and for its failure to convey the human dimension of the prisoners’ wrestle.
Whereas the Fee’s report might have grazed on the edges of the violence dedicated by the state, it “stops brief, nevertheless, in condemning these liable for the Bloodbath, rationalizing and justifying whereas by no means pinpointing these whose selections led to cold-blooded homicide.” The author famous that the Fee concluded, appropriately, that “the usage of shotguns not solely elevated the danger however nearly assured the demise or severe harm of harmless individuals within the contested confines of D-yard.”
However the author was essential of how the report handled the revolt. “The precise rebellion by the prisoners, the seize of the guards as hostages, and the institution of D-Block yard as a base of operations is handled very calmly,” the Pa’ahao Press defined. “Whereas the report comprises all of the details and logistics of the seizure, once more, the human issue, the feelings, the sense of sacrifice and trigger, falls outdoors its realm.”
Deciphering occasions from an incarcerated perspective, the contributor claimed the rationale behind “the seize of the guards as hostages and the proposals for alternate (alternate of the guards without cost, protected transport to a ‘non-imperialist nation’) was that it was an try to avoid wasting life not take it. The prisoner rebellion at Attica was a press release of life, of human concern for survival with dignity, addressing all-too-clearly the backwards and armed forces of racism, exploitation and demise.”
“One 12 months later,” the incarcerated mental surmised, “the reminiscence of Attica lingers.” Certainly, “whereas the useless have been buried and the Bloodbath etched into our troubled historical past, the spirit of Attica, of religion, dedication and wrestle stays”—or, it a minimum of continued to course by way of the corridors and cell blocks the place human beings stay confined.
The Pa’ahao Press ran an intensive historical past of Attica-related occasions up that time—“A Chronology of Resistance”—of their February 1973 issue (incorrectly dated 1972). The creator mentions 60 prisoners—and no authorities—had been indicted to date in reference to the rebellion, regardless of the very fact “39 of the 43 males who died at Attica in September 1971 had been killed by state troopers, guards, sheriff’s deputies and nationwide guardsmen.” Because the unnamed creator recounted, the administration threw some 70 prisoners, suspected of being “leaders” in the course of the revolt into segregation for nearly eight months, confining every in a cell practically 24 hours per day with out sneakers and with only one change of underwear per week.
The chronology cites the McKay Fee report, which acknowledged prisoners who organized the revolt dedicated “to work in a democratic trend” with the administration to understand elementary modifications, like “an finish to unsanitary circumstances that exist within the mess corridor” —an issue still relevant on the inside today. The Fee’s report, per the Pa’ahao Press historical past, acknowledged incarcerated individuals must be “granted the best to help their very own households” with dwelling wages. In 2022, some states don’t supply even nominal wages to prisoners—slavery as punishment, à la the Thirteenth Amendment—with others paying pennies per hour.
Regardless of calls for for higher healthcare being a central impetus behind the rebellion, lower than a 12 months later the healthcare scenario at Attica was nonetheless a supply of stress. In July of 1972, 900 males reportedly went on a piece strike to demand “the rehiring of the nurse and a gathering between Commissioner Oswald and Ernest Montanye—the brand new warden—members of the press and the Inmate Liaison Committee…” Once more, they had been taking drastic measures making an attempt to drive sufficient care.
Montanye refused to allow attorneys or media to enter in the course of the three-day lock-in, and authorities put a minimum of two males in segregation for collaborating. Then, on Black Solidarity Day, November 8, 1972, about 250 prisoners engaged in a celebratory protest within the yard. Clearly disregarding the suggestions of the McKay fee, guards confirmed up in “vests filled with ammunition” with gasoline weapons, shotguns, machine weapons in hand, and officers threw 100 males in segregation for the incident the subsequent day, based on the newspaper’s historical past.
Later that month, prisoners produced their “Manifesto from the Monster Attica,” which reiterated calls for much like these issued the 12 months earlier than, evidently unanswered and unaddressed in gentle of the state Fee’s report. “Right here in Attica, Superintendent Montanye permits our most simple calls for for medical, schooling and vocation enhancements to go unanswered,” pointing as an alternative to a newly constructed gymnasium as proof the place has modified, based on a scathing critique republished within the Pa’ahao Press.
The paper revealed a number of paragraphs from the November 1972 manifesto, together with feedback that its authors in Attica had been “nonetheless ready for the legislature to make the modifications that fall inside their jurisdiction,” and “nonetheless ready for Commissioner Oswald and Superintendent Montanye to meet their a part of the discount agreed to in D-block yard on September 13, 1971.”
The piece reprinted a harrowing vow from the November 1972 calls for, “our resistance will proceed”,” a promise saved not solely by veteran organizers at Attica, but in addition by prisoners elsewhere who wrote and examine their work through the newspapers circulating inside. Lately, when resistance resurfaced with a prisoner strike in Alabama, these concerned proclaimed, “We’re human beings,” harkening again to the cry of Attica prisoners circa 1971, “We’re males.” Greater than fifty years later, the humanity of incarcerated folks must be asserted.
Support JSTOR Daily! Join our new membership program on Patreon today.
